My Envelopes are showing negative. Why?!


EEBA is now Goodbudget! Goodbudget has all the great features of EEBA (and more!) in a new and updated interface. Check out our updated article on this topic, and check out the Goodbudget Help Center for the most recent help content.

Q: I’m recording transactions using EEBA, but my envelopes are all showing red/negative. Why?

In most cases, the confusion is that in the envelope budgeting method, you have to fill your envelopes *first* and *then* spend out of them.

When you Set Up Your Budgets initially, we don’t automatically fill your envelopes with money for you. You can do that using “Add $” on your Android phone or “Envelopes…Add Money” on the website.

At the beginning of the month (for example; or whichever budgeting period you choose), you would fill your envelopes. Then throughout the month, you take money out of them as you pay for various things.

You may find this video to be helpful with respect to how Envelope Budgeting works:

And this video may also be helpful for how EEBA works with respect to syncing to phones (if you’re using an Android)

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Get the latest in budgeting content — straight into your inbox.

Thank you!

See you in your inbox.

Search for


Say hello to Goodbudget

  1. A strong philosophy.
    Transform your financial life with the Goodbudget Way.
  2. A time-tested system.
    Goodbudget is based on the envelope budgeting method.
  3. Great budget software.
    Available for the Web, Android, and iPhone. Get started with Goodbudget. Sign up now!

Get Help




2 thoughts on “My Envelopes are showing negative. Why?!”

  1. How do you handle Credit card usage? I have a really tight budget that doesn’t account for Miscellaneous expenses. Right now I have an envelope for Credit card payments and I just pay for unexpected expenses on a credit card and use that bulk of the credit card envelope to pay it back down.

Comments are closed.